Books Like Once Upon a Broken Heart

🌶️ 1/5 MagicalAtmosphericSlow Burn

Evangeline Fox makes a deal with Jacks — the Prince of Hearts, who can make anyone fall in love — to stop a wedding. The price: three kisses. Simple. Except nothing with Jacks is ever simple, and the

Find Once Upon a Broken Heart on Amazon Full Profile →

You just finished Once Upon a Broken Heart and now everything else on your Kindle feels... flat. That magical energy? The way Stephanie Garber made you feel things you didn't sign up for? Yeah, we get it. That's a book hangover, and the only cure is another book that hits the same way. We didn't just search "books like Once Upon a Broken Heart" and call it a day. We broke down exactly what made this book land — the mood, the tropes, the pacing, the heat — and found books that match on the elements that actually matter.

12 Books Matched to Once Upon a Broken Heart

Grouped by the elements that made Once Upon a Broken Heart unforgettable.

The Fantasy World You'll Want to Move Into

An Enchantment of Ravens

by Margaret Rogerson

🌶️ 1/5 · 304p

You loved Once Upon a Broken Heart for the atmospheric and slow burn and forbidden romance? An Enchantment of Ravens is your next obsession. Same emotional frequency, different story — and Margaret Rogerson might just become your new auto-buy author.

Find on Amazon →

Birthday Girl

by Penelope Douglas

🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ 4/5 · 348p

Birthday Girl hits the same slow burn and forbidden and forbidden romance notes that made Once Upon a Broken Heart impossible to put down. Penelope Douglas brings forbidden and intense to every page.

Find on Amazon →

Credence

by Penelope Douglas

🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ 5/5 · 448p

You loved Once Upon a Broken Heart for the atmospheric and forbidden and forbidden romance? Credence is your next obsession. Same emotional frequency, different story — and Penelope Douglas might just become your new auto-buy author.

Find on Amazon →

Our #1 Pick After Once Upon a Broken Heart

An Enchantment of Ravens by Margaret Rogerson — 🌶️ 1/5 spice, 304 pages

Find on Amazon

Explore by Mood

Magical Atmospheric Slow Burn Forbidden

Explore by Trope

Morally Grey Love Interest Deal with the Devil Forbidden Romance Fairytale World

FAQ

Questions About Books Like Once Upon a Broken Heart

Based on mood, trope, and pacing analysis, the most similar books to Once Upon a Broken Heart include An Enchantment of Ravens, Birthday Girl, Credence. Each matches on specific elements like magical and atmospheric that made Once Upon a Broken Heart resonate with readers.

We recommend starting with An Enchantment of Ravens by Margaret Rogerson — it shares Once Upon a Broken Heart's core Magical energy while bringing something fresh to the table.

Yes — Once Upon a Broken Heart is part of the Once Upon a Broken Heart series (book 6). Check Stephanie Garber's author page for the full reading order.

Once Upon a Broken Heart has a spice level of 1/5. The recommendations on this page range across spice levels — each one is labeled so you can find your comfort zone.

Once Upon a Broken Heart is already a low-spice read (1/5). Most similar books on this page have comparable heat levels.

Get your weekly match

One handpicked book every Friday — matched to your mood, spice level, and reading style. Zero spoilers.

Join 5,000+ readers who get better recs · spoiler-free · every Friday

How these profiles are built

Every Sort By Cravings profile is written after a full read-through — not scraped from publisher blurbs. We cross-reference BookTok discussions, Goodreads reviews, and 500+ reader reactions before publishing any mood tag, spice rating, or compatibility note. Read our editorial standards.